What You'll Find at Reservoir Hill Park

Reservoir Hill Park sits on the eastern edge of Pagosa Springs and holds a small impoundment that draws locals year-round for trout. The water runs cold and clear, fed by snowmelt and mountain springs, and holds a mix of rainbow and brown trout in the 10- to 16-inch range. The park itself is modest — a few parking spots, a short walk to the water, and enough bank access for wade fishing or casting from shore. It's not a destination lake that requires a day trip from out of state, but it's exactly the kind of place where Pagosa residents slip away for an hour or two before work or after.

The reservoir sits at roughly 7,400 feet elevation, so water temperature and fish behavior follow the mountain calendar. Spring runoff can muddy the water and push fish deep. Summer brings steady fishing from dawn through mid-morning, then a slowdown in the heat. Fall is reliable — water cools, fish feed actively, and the crowds thin out. Winter fishing is possible but requires patience and the right conditions.

Key Takeaways

  • Reservoir Hill Park holds rainbow and brown trout in the 10- to 16-inch range and is open year-round for wade and shore fishing.
  • You'll need a Colorado fishing license and must follow state regulations, including catch limits and gear restrictions that vary by season.
  • Early morning and late evening produce the most consistent action, especially in summer when midday heat slows the bite.
  • The park has limited facilities — a small parking area and basic access — so plan for a short session rather than a full day.

What Gear and Tackle Work Best

Trout at Reservoir Hill respond to small, natural patterns. Bring a 5- to 6-weight fly rod if you're a fly angler, or a light spinning rod with 4- to 6-pound test if you prefer conventional tackle. The water is clear, so match the hatch and use thin tippet — 4X to 5X fluorocarbon works well for fly fishing.

For flies, small nymphs dominate: Pheasant Tail, Hare's Ear, and Copper Johns in sizes 14 to 18 catch fish consistently. Dry flies work during evening rises, especially small Adams and Pale Morning Duns. If you're spinning, use 1/16- to 1/8-ounce spinners in silver or gold, or small spoons. Avoid heavy lures — the water is shallow in places and the trout are selective.

The reservoir has structure — drop-offs, weed beds, and rocky points — so spend time reading the water. Fish the deeper sections in midday heat and move to shallower banks in early morning and evening. A pair of polarized sunglasses helps you spot fish and avoid spooking them in the clear water.

Seasonal Patterns and Best Times to Fish

Spring (April through May) brings runoff that can cloud the water for weeks. Fish move to deeper, clearer pockets and feed less aggressively. If you fish during runoff, focus on the inlet where clearer water enters and on the dam face where depth provides refuge. Nymphs fished deep work better than dry flies.

Summer (June through August) is the most predictable season. Fish early — sunrise to mid-morning — when water is coolest and trout feed actively. By 10 a.m., the bite often slows as water warms and light intensifies. Evening fishing from 6 p.m. onward can be excellent, especially if a hatch develops. Midday is a good time to scout new water or take a break.

Fall (September through October) offers some of the year's best fishing. Water cools, fish feed throughout the day, and the park is less crowded. This is the time to experiment with larger flies and more aggressive presentations. Winter (November through March) is slower but not impossible — fish move deep and feed less, but clear, cold days can produce if you're patient and use small nymphs fished slowly.

Access, Parking, and What to Bring

Reservoir Hill Park is accessible from the east side of Pagosa Springs via a short drive on local roads. Parking is limited to a small lot — typically 6 to 8 spaces — so arrive early on weekends or plan your visit for a weekday. The walk from the parking area to the water is short, usually less than a quarter mile, and the trail is easy to follow.

Bring water and snacks — there are no facilities at the park. A small backpack, waders or wade boots, and a net are standard. Sunscreen and a hat are essential at elevation, even on cool days. If you're fishing in fall or winter, bring layers; mountain weather can shift quickly. A headlamp is useful if you plan to fish into dusk.

Colorado Fishing License and Regulations

You must have a valid Colorado fishing license to fish Reservoir Hill Park. A one-day license is available if you're visiting, or you can purchase an annual license. Licenses are sold online through Colorado Parks and Wildlife or at local sporting goods shops in Pagosa Springs.

Check the current regulations for this specific water — catch limits, minimum sizes, and gear restrictions can change. Colorado Parks and Wildlife publishes an annual fishing guide and maintains a website with up-to-date rules by region. As of recent years, many mountain reservoirs in this area allow two trout per day with a 10-inch minimum, but verify before you fish. Some waters have special restrictions on bait or require catch-and-release only during certain seasons.

Nearby Water and Alternative Options

If Reservoir Hill is crowded or the fishing is slow, the San Juan River runs through Pagosa Springs and offers excellent trout habitat. The river is larger and deeper than the reservoir, with more consistent flows and a broader range of fish sizes. It requires wading skills and a different approach, but it's worth exploring if you have time.

Navajo Lake, about 30 minutes north, is a larger reservoir with more facilities and a wider range of fish species, including kokanee salmon and larger trout. It's a better choice if you want to spend a full day or if you're fishing with family members who want more amenities. Smaller mountain lakes in the high country around Pagosa Springs offer solitude and wild cutthroat trout, but they require hiking and are best visited in summer and early fall.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

The most common mistake is fishing too late in the day during summer. By the time many anglers arrive in the afternoon, the bite has already shut down. Plan to be on the water at first light or plan an evening session starting at least two hours before sunset.

Overpowering the water is another trap. Reservoir Hill is small and clear, and trout here are easily spooked by heavy casts, loud footsteps, or shadows on the water. Wade slowly, keep your profile low, and use longer, finer tippet than you think you need. Many anglers also fish too fast — trout in cool mountain water feed deliberately. Slow your retrieve, fish deep, and give flies time to sink.

Finally, don't ignore the weather forecast. Spring and fall storms can arrive quickly at elevation, and afternoon thunderstorms are common in summer. Check the forecast before you go, and be prepared to leave if weather turns dangerous.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need waders to fish Reservoir Hill Park?

No, but they help. You can fish from shore and reach much of the water by wading in boots, especially in late summer and fall when water levels drop. Waders give you more access and keep you dry and warm in spring and fall, so they're worth bringing if you have them.

What's the best time of year to fish here?

Fall (September through October) offers the most consistent fishing and fewer crowds. Summer early mornings are also excellent. Spring runoff can muddy the water for weeks, and winter is slow but possible on clear, calm days.

Can I fish here with bait?

Check the current regulations with Colorado Parks and Wildlife before you fish. Some mountain reservoirs allow bait, others restrict to flies and lures only. The rules can change, so verify online or call ahead.

How far is Reservoir Hill Park from downtown Pagosa Springs?

It's about 3 to 4 miles from the town center, a 10-minute drive. It's close enough for a quick morning or evening session if you're staying in town.

What if the parking lot is full?

The lot is small, so it fills quickly on weekends. Visit on a weekday if possible, or plan an early morning arrival. If the lot is full, the San Juan River offers alternative access nearby, though it requires different skills and gear.